Nicholas Leeming, major client director of propertyfinder.com:
Where HIPs are concerned, the only thing the government has been consistent on is indecision. The main impact on the market has been from dithering over implementation, rather than the actual legislation. Now that HIPs are compulsory for almost all properties, they are just an expensive, unavoidable inconvenience – much like death and taxes.
Where were they introduced?
The legislation was initially intended to speed up the process of buying and selling a home by making vital information on a property available to buyers upfront. This would prevent people pulling out of purchases further down the line. But after several U-turns, the government burdened the market with a diluted HIP that does not provide the information a buyer needs. Without a structural survey, a buyer and their mortgage lender don’t have the information to guarantee they can proceed with buying the property.
Agent Response
Agents tell me HIPs have done nothing to speed up transactions for this reason – there’s nothing in them of use. Buyers aren’t even looking at them and don’t ask to see them. Solicitors often refuse to rely on the information they contain.
EPCs
Supporters (mostly those with a vested interest) make a lot of positive noise about EPCs. But buying a home is an emotive process and the energy efficiency of the property will not influence the decision of the vast majority of buyers. HIPs have become about complying with an EU directive on reducing carbon emissions, not about helping buyers and sellers of property.
New Build Properties
Which is precisely why this pointless legislation is being extended to recent new build properties. New properties are built to the latest building regulatory standards. A HIP won’t tell buyers anything new but with guaranteed high standards of energy efficiency, dragging them under the legislative net will undoubtedly boost the government’s energy efficiency statistics. So the government can furnish their green credentials at the expense of others. The only other outcome of extending the reach of HIPs will be to create work to placate the HIP providers who suffered from the earlier indecision and are now struggling in a slower housing market.